Book Review: First Famous Christmas by Carrie Wittmer

I recently purchased First Famous Christmas by Carrie Wittmer from 831 Stories. They announced the book on Instagram, and I was excited to check out their first Christmas book release. It’s about a violin prodigy named Marceline Freeze, who becomes a famous musician after graduating from Juilliard.

Everybody knows her face, as well as her music. So in an attempt to get away from the hustle and bustle of fame, she travels hope to her small North Carolina hometown for the holidays. It will be great to spend some quality time with her family. But while there, she realizes that the guy who she was infatuated with as a teen still lives in town.

Is First Famous Christmas by Carrie Wittmer worth adding to your holiday reading list? We’ll find out in today’s book review.

What is First Famous Christmas by Carrie Wittmer About?

After rocketing to pop stardom practically overnight, all Marceline wants is a calm holiday at home. What she gets is a run-in with her bad-boy high-school crush, Lucas. Could this Ghost of Christmas Past also become her new muse?

When Marceline Freeze went to Juilliard to study violin, she didn’t expect it to lead to a Best New Artist Grammy. Now, after a whirlwind tour and early-onset fame fatigue, she’s looking forward to a normal Christmas in her snowy North Carolina hometown. But all bets are off the second she walks into My Place, the coffee shop that was her refuge growing up. It’s gotten an infuriating Scandi-chic makeover courtesy of its new owner: Lucas North, the rebellious firestarter she worshipped from afar as a teenager. (from Amazon.com)

Some Romantic Tropes Featured in This Book:

  • Hometown holiday return
  • Celebrity heroine meets small-town hero
  • Old rivals who become love interests
  • A creative block that needs fixing before the next album

My Initial Thoughts

I have to be honest. After reading the first couple of chapters I was like, wait… Is this Lindsay Stirling Fan Fiction?

And that’s coming from someone who knows nothing about Lindsay Stirling, besides the fact that she went on multiple Christmas tours. Haha.

It’s obviously not, but that is immediately who my mind went to when I started learning more abour the main character, Marceline. The way her fame was described, it also made me think of Taylor Swift. Especially when she was first trying to head home for the holidays and caused a MAJOR scene in the airport.

I Loved The Small Town Vibes

As a huge fan of romantic Christmas movies and books, I love a small town. But not all small towns are created equal. It’s very important to me that the author/writer put a lot of effort into creating unique businesses, as well as interesting backstories and personalities for the people that run them.

I think Carrie Wittmer did a good job of creating Hope Gap. I found the characters to be realistic and funny. I loved how Marceline’s older sister was the bookkeeper for basically every small business in town. I found it funny when Marceline went to Gertie’s, or to the bookstore, and had humorous interactions with people from her past.

Stars Hollow (from Gilmore Girls) will always be the ultimate fiction small town in my mind, and I definitely felt those vibes in this story.

What I Liked

Something that I’ve noticed about the books published through 831 Stories is that these are fun, snappy, romances. The plotlines are interesting and fun, and maybe not the most unique, but it doesn’t matter. The point is that they tell a romance story that will captivate readers.

That is definitely how I felt about this book. I liked being absorbed into Marceline’s world, and learning about her dynamic with her friends and family back home. I liked the weird tension between her and Lucas as they got to know each other again. It felt like a simple love story about two people who missed their chance when they were younger.

What I Didn’t Like

However, I did feel some millenial cringe while ready this story. And that’s saying a lot because I am a millenial. I’m 34 years old. And there were some scenes that definitely made me cringe.

The references to music were fun, but they also felt a little immature. It seemed crazy to me that in her life of fame and fortune, Marceline would still be thinking about mix cd’s that Lucas made her when she was a teenager. Especially when it seems like they didn’t really know each other that well.

The banter between them was good, but they also went from 0 to 100 really quickly. I don’t necessarily mind that in a romance, but in this case it felt kind of random. I did like this story, but it also felt a little bit like the cringe-y romance stories that I published on fictionpress in the early 00’s.

Would I Recommend This Book?

Yes. Although I did find it cringe-y at times, I did also enjoy it. I think it is a fun romance to read at Christmastime and I do plan to lend it to my best friend. There’s just something fun about the rock star/normal person falling in love trope, especially during the holiday season. While not everything worked for me, I did think it was a solid 3-3.5 star read.

In Conclusion

Thanks for stopping by the blog today to read my book review of First Famous Christmas by Carrie Wittmer. If you’re looking for a quick Christmas novella to read this holiday season, it just might be the book for you! I’m slowly working my way through the 831 stories romance backlist, so you can expect more romantic book review coming soon.

Join the List

You'll Also Love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *